Aqua Resist Graphic Pen - Eyeliner

Don't buy this.

I generally have loved other products I've received from this brand, but this eyeliner is a nightmare. It's difficult to apply and bleeds like crazy but is also somehow a difficult to remove! I've just been doing eyeliner on a naked eye lately, so thankfully it's not ruining my whole look when I remove it, but it's still terrible. I wouldn't wish this eyeliner on my worst enemy. I got a free sample so thankfully I did not waste money on this product. Do yourself a favor and avoid this one.

Perfect

Absolutely love it!!! It stays on all day, super easy to make a wing and is superrr dark black!!

This liner fades off if you try to go back over the line to make it darker and/or thicker. It was a waste of money and I wished I could have returned it. NEVER AGAIN!

Didn’t hold well :(

Decided to invest in a product I thought would be better than my usual elf eyeliner , and I was super happy for the first like 2 hours. It cracked and smudged into my eyelid folds. Going back to my elf :( isn’t worth

Teste yeux bridés

Ayant les yeux brider il transfère peu comparer au fentybeauty qui est quand mm pas mal, reciste a l’eau mais peu a la sueur ou encore au sebum gros point négatif il s’est secher en -1an pour un produit aussi chere je mattendais a mieux le fenty dure plus longtemps mais na pas les mm résultats que j’attend.

My go to one !

Love this liner . I am Bharatnatyam( Indian classical dance) performer & need to make bold eyes for my performances. This one became so easy to use . Its my most favorite eye makeup tool now .

Love but does dry up really quick

I love this product but it dries up. I didn't do makeup for a while and it sat nicely in my drawer, closed tightly. Just went to try it and it's dry. Ugh. Any other ones from other brands I have aren't dry but this one is my fav and dried up. I also had a mini I carry with me and it's dry too. I'll repurchase but don't let it sit for too long as it apparently becomes unusable. Did last through summertime, Disneyland, parks with my kid, etc. Thankfully it's pretty cheap.

Great liner!

Love this in black but I often want something slightly more subtle. Doesn’t transfer (even with my oily lids) all day. Please make in dark brown!

Sticky tarry mess.

0/10 not reworkable. Feathers … horribly. Sticky. Impossible to remove because it’s tarry and will require several removals. Returning.

Doesn’t apply evenly

This used to be great but I feel like they changed something. The last couple times I bought it, it felt dried out and impossible to get even right from the start. Will not buy again. Can companies stop changing stuff????

Smudge easily

I received a sample version before and it was very long lasting. For some reason this regular one that I purchased smudged very easily.

Want to love it…

I wanted to love this so badly, but the one I recieved had hardly any pigment. Unsure if I just got a bad batch since some of the reviews are showing it super pigmented but what little pigment mine had was smudging pretty quick.