I liked this when I first applied it but after taking it off noticed that my skin was red where it had been applied and this happened every time I used it.

Doesn’t get on contacts!

The only waterline liner that doesn’t get all over my contacts! I’ve tried SO MANY different liners! My only gripe is there aren’t more colors!

It’s very good!

Stays on for hours, doesn’t smudge and makes your eyes look dramatic! Beautiful precision, comes with a pencil sharpener and smudge tip if you’re into that. Smooth application.

A no for me

Nor impressed, did not last- got muddy looking throughout the day.

Favorite eyeliner

I love this eyeliner!! It takes about 20 minutes to fully dry so if you aren’t careful it can smudge. This eyeliner goes on soooo smooth which is really important to me because I put it on my waterline. Ca

Not smooth

The eyeliner does not go on smooth and pulls on skin. I tried wearing a few times and then in the garbage it went.

Terrible eyeliner

This is a terrible eyeliner, don't buy. It's hard and crumbly, which makes it impossible to draw a smooth line. Pieces break off when I'm trying to twist it up out of the pencil. The sharpener doesn't work well and the smudge attachment is useless because the eyeliner is so dry it's not smudgeable! It's also hard to wash off even with makeup remover. Wish I returned it when I had the chance.

I wish I could give it 0 stars

The worst makeup product I have probably ever used. This batch must be 2 years old that I got. Tips broke off first time trying (not even applying hard). Doesn’t go on smooth it’s really dry. Just absolute trash. I purchased 2 colors from the milk makeup website, both terrible

Very dry formula - disappointing

I found this eyeliner very disappointing. It dried out very quickly (in a matter of a couple of weeks). Because the formula was so dry, it was not very easy to smudge with the soft blending tip.

Not a fan

I wish this worked for me, but it really didn’t. I have attempted to use this one about 3-4 times and each time I’m really not a fan. You have to press down pretty hard for good pigmentation which results in the stick breaking off in little pieces on your eyelid. Not creamy whatsoever and it did smudge off super easily, so not good for people who may occasionally, accidentally scratch or rub their eye. This product doesn’t work for a good wing in my opinion. I like regular liner pencils, but this one just does not work to create a pointed wing.

This is a good eyeliner! I have oily lids so it still smudges a little

Sweat proof and long lasting.

This eyeliner is one of the best! I love how creamy the formula is. It doesn’t smudge and it very long lasting.