My go-to eyeliner

Genuinely obsessed with this eyeliner and color. I tight line and this goes on so easily and stays pigmented all day. It also doesn’t smudge throughout the day even in hot weather which is great!

Loved it, but dries out quickly

Was looking for a nice gel eyeliner to replace my Marc Jacobs liner since it was discontinued. When I first started using it I loved the way it glided on my water line, it was long lasting + waterproof, and easy enough for me to use. However, now, the formula is pretty dried out and the pencil breaks frequently on me now. I would say these pencils aren’t something that will last a while in your makeup bag, but they are a beautiful product to use. I will be trying out their 1.5mm mechanical liner next.

Will break off!!!!

The color is beautiful but this is the most flimsy eyeliner I have ever used. It broke after one use and is no longer usable. Price point for ONE USE- that’s ridiculous.

Not worth the price- thought I was buying luxury

Pros: it is waterproof and stays put all day; nice dark brown almost black color (cave brown) Cons: is thicker than you’d expect for a “thin” pencil liner, messy, dries super quick and is hard to smudge or smooth out the mess from how it applies onto skin.

Awesome. Deep, rich pigment. Goes on smoothly and stays put. Have to work fast if you want to smudge it. I am going to get other colors.

Nice color and staying power

The eyeliner stays put. I do like it. The color is good.

Something needs to change

The product was fine from what I got to use before the entire pencil part fell straight out of the tube.

Beautiful but…

I LOVE this eyeliner and the way it just glides on so easily. Literally the one negative and it is a pretty big one is that it falls apart/ the color pencil part just fell out of the top. My friend experienced the same thing. Please fix

Pigmented but doesn't last

Smears and is costly. It is very pigmented but doesn't last throughout day. Didn't irritate my eyes which is good.

CHEF’S KISS

If you like to fill in your waterline this eyeliner is for you! It will not smudge this one is better to apply than the mechanical one. The color obsidian is the one I like because of its deep, dark look.

Color is great, but...

The color is great, but it is really dry and does not roll on the eyelids smoothly

Smudged!

This eyeliner fell short of my expectations as it smudged excessively, leaving marks on my skin throughout the day.